Best Cum Lubes:
The 5 Most Realistic Fake Cum Products I've Tried

Written by: Angela Watson | Updated: March 24th, 2019

In Case You're In A Hurry, Here's My Favorite Cum Lube:

My criteria for these products was fairly simple. It's cum lube, right? So how good is it at being cum and how good is it at being lube? Master Series Jizz is great at both.


With a nearly spot on color and sheen compared to the real thing, it's a water based cum lube that's even semen scented. The other things about spooge like viscosity and general dynamics is replicated well while also being an extremely function lube. I was worried it would either be too runny or become sticky too quickly, but it has some real staying power just like a natural money shot. Being water based, it's condom safe and won't interact with any toys. These guys take the cake.

The sex toy & adult pleasure industry is a vast, diverse ocean that can be a little jarring to the uninitiated, maybe even disgusting to those with more puritanical tastes than others. That hasn't stopped the industry from blossoming to cover just about every kinky fantasy a man or woman can have.

That brings us to the idea of fake cum. The idea of replicating male ejaculate for the carnal desire it can bring out in people has been a goal for many, with some even going as far as making their own fake semen.

The ideal fake semen mimics the color, viscosity, and texture of the real thing. Bonus points if it's edible and tastes desirable too. That last attribute is what eludes most manufacturers to this day. 

Also, fake cum typically also doubles as essentially cum lube too, so the purposes it is supposed to serve casts a pretty wide net.

Some people choose to put this fake cum inside of a squirting dildo to replicate the experience of someone ejaculating inside of them, while others just like the look it can add to a sexual experience while also giving everything some much-needed lubrication.

We've delved deep into the world of replica ejaculates so you don't have to, and here are the standouts as far as we're concerned:

The Best Cum Lubes

Master Series Jizz (Editors Choice)

What makes the Master Series water-based cum lube so interesting is that it also boasts being semen scented. That means some very pocket-protected scientists all got together and distilled the essence of jizzum down to a single scent chemical and then found the best ways to replicate that scent.


The scent is best tested while in use, if you smell directly from the bottle it'll be a bit overpowering.


The Jizz water-based lube is great because it washes out easily, is compatible with all kinds of sex toys, and won't degrade condoms if you're trying to use it during protected sex.


It is extremely white in color, the perfect level of clearness, pretty spot-on as far as viscosity goes and the scent is unmistakably that of cum. It isn't as sticky as the real thing so it functions great as lube, it is extremely slick.


It looks extremely real and is easy to clean, but where it doesn't stack up is in the taste department. Don't, and I really mean don't get any of this in your mouth. It tastes awful.

Doc Johnson Nutt Butter (Runner Up)

Here's another water-silicone hybrid lube that does a great job at replicating what is now my favorite term for ejaculate, man relish.


The feel between your fingers of hybrid lube is definitely different than the water-based options and gets a little closer to that odd texture that real semen has when rubbed between the fingers.


It is not as white as other options but if you have enough of it in a single place it will be hard to see through, so it's kind of like the semen from a man who knows how to hydrate himself. What I'm trying to say is that it is translucent in nature.


Its body-safe but not compatible with silicone toys, won't stain and has little to no scent to speak of.


This product is a favorite of my transgender clients who want to be able to replicate having some realistic ejaculate to play around with in their sex life, as it offers one of the most realistic feel out of option of fake semen options.

Bad Dragon Cum Lube (Best Bulk Option)

Our next entry for worthwhile fake semen is none other than Bad Dragon Cumlube. Boasting a fantastic texture and consistency from a water-based formula, it is another great option for those who have bukkake or pearl necklace fantasies that they'd like satiated without all of the hassle of organizing a real life orgy.


Cumlube comes unscented and is extremely delicate on the skin, I recommend this one for anyone who's worried that they might have an allergic reaction to other products as it is quite delicate.


These types of water-based lubes tend to fare better in the slickness and longevity department that most other water-based lubes because the consistency expected of a semen stand-in makes for a long-lasting lube regardless of purpose. It is compatible with condoms and all variety of sex toys, which makes it a great choice if you want an unscented option for your ejaculating dildo.


It is unscented and unflavored, aka the flavor is less than appealing. It has more of a plain taste compared to actual cum.


I've actually written a full review of the Bad Dragon Cum Lube if you'd like to learn more about it.

Squirtz Cum Lube by Cyberskin

Here's another unscented and unflavored option for those who just want the look and feel with none of the less desirable aspects of semen.


It's entirely water-based but just a dime-sized amount goes longer than you'd think so don't over apply when using it as lubrication, its much better lubricant than it is eye candy and it does a pretty good job at both.


It's probably the easiest out of all of them to clean up on this list too, which is a major plus if you like to use a lot or just get carried away. It isn't extremely runny, just enough to get that perfect spread typical of a worthwhile money shot.


The water-based formula is also extremely gentle on the skin and we use it as lube without much care for the semen aspect very often because of how satisfied we are with it.


Squirtz is 100% toy safe and condom compatible, so you can use this cum lubricant however your heart desires. If you're looking for  a realistic cum lube that is unscented and feels, looks, smells, plus even tastes like cum, then Squirtz cum lube is worth checking out.


It's a fantastic lubricant besides all of the semen-esque aspects, so that's another plus.

Spunk Lube

Not like any of the others had much subtlety to them, but after looking at a bottle of Spunk Lube you already know exactly what you're going to receive.


This lube is referred to as a hybrid lube because it is a mixture of water-based and silicone-based lube, making something in between. This means it lasts longer than the water-based only options and has a creamier consistency but it also means it is incompatible with silicone-based toys.


It is non-staining, slightly scented in our opinion (smells not like cum but like debauchery, if that makes sense), and is not appealing in the flavor department.


It does a fantastic job at mimicking the real deal and is a pinch better at a few of the attributes of cum compared to water-based lubes but is still easy to wash off and won't ruin your sheets.


The consistency, texture, thickness, and slight stickiness of the real thing are all present with Spunk Lube and for that, we applaud the manufacturer. 


There's no real taste to speak of, but I don't recommend going out of your way to eat lots of it.

Conclusion

If you're on a budget or would simply rather make your own fake cum/cum lube, I've created a simple guide that walks you through a few different fake cum recipes. Since I know some people would rather make their own at home instead of ordering a pre-packaged product.


There you have it, five of the most worthwhile options as far as fake cum goes. We also tried the Bad Dragon cum lube, but we found it was way too stringy and difficult to clean to be worthwhile, it's a much less well thought out product overall in our humble opinion.


So all of those who are feeling a little peckish in the bedroom or have a semen fetish, your prayers have been answered. If you plan on using these in an ejaculating dildo, make sure to get the entirely water-based options. The hybrids say they are compatible with silicone-based toys, but use at your own risk as silicone-based lubes are known to contribute to the breakdown of silicone toys.

About Angela Watson

I'm a sex therapist by day and a sex blogger by night. I love to crush the taboos surrounding sex toys and help people become more sexually liberated. There's no topic too risqué for me to cover and I hope to educate and inform my readers on all things sex. All things that concern the female anatomy or require a more clinical approach than my husband Don can provide is covered by me.

Leave a Reply 3 comments

Karina - March 24, 2019 Reply

So, I’ve tried both Masters Series and Bad Dragon. They’re both really good when I use them with my special squirting dildo. The taste leaves little to be desired but the texture and look is pretty spot on with both. I’d say the Bad Dragon tastes a bit better, but the Masters Series is probably the more realistic of the two. It’s got a more realistic level of a stringiness which is normally present in real cum whereas I find Bad Dragon to be a bit too stringy.

Maybe I’ll give some of the others on this list a shot…

Grail - May 3, 2019 Reply

Hi Angela,

I just read a review you did on artificial semen.. and I’m just confused… I’m a guy who’s looking to no longer fight the urge and what’s to see what it’s like to go down on a penis.. so if I buy a squirting dildo I know have to find semen I will swallow! I’ve read reviews on the products like spunk and dragon and they all say taste like glue or etc.

Is there a fake semen you have found that u can suggest for me that I can swallow?

I know u can make it with a recipe but I don’t really want to Julia Child’s up my kitchen to simulate a sex act on my own…

Thanks
Grail

    Angela Watson - May 5, 2019 Reply

    Well, out of the cum lubes on this page, go with Bad Dragon if you want the most flavor with not much concern for any of the other attributes, I find it the most palatable. If you can handle the lube not looking exactly like cum, my personal favorite lube in the flavor department is the cotton candy lube from Crazy Girl, it’s on our list of best tasting lubes but if you just want to take a look at it quick here’s a link: https://amzn.to/2AW6wRI

Leave a Reply: