The Search For The Best Onahole Has Ended:

Ranked Top Picks & More!

Written by: Don Watson | Updated: December 16th, 2020

Firstly I'd like to say that this variety of male stroker is very heavily dipped in Japanese sensibility. That's exactly where the name Onahole comes from, anyways. In my experience for something to be an "onahole all it needs is an orifice to insert into and be vaguely skin colored and penis shaped.

Most often they take the form of straight shot vaginas but it isn't out of the question for an Onahole to be an entire lower torso or even an entire woman just scaled down into a handheld toy.

That means there is no one main manufacturer and no real accepted definition of an Onahole, other than it needs to have some Japanese influence and be a male stroker of some kind. It's essentially just the Japanese term for any toy that's similar to a Fleshlight, except usually without the hard plastic exterior.

The overseas origin of this toy is also very important because it comes from a place that develop its sex toy industry & associated culture completely independently. There are a lot of things western toy producers wouldn't even consider doing that seem to be standard fare for the world of the Onahole.

One thing there isn't a lot of is discussion as to worthwhile Onaholes, this might be because of the nature of sexual privacy in Japan or just a victim of circumstance.

In my book, a good Onahole is easy to use & clean, feels good, won't end up in the trash a week later, and most importantly was worth the price in the first place.

That means there is no one main manufacturer and no real accepted definition of an Onahole, other than it needs to have some Japanese influence and be a male stroker of some kind. It's essentially just the Japanese term for any toy that's similar to a Fleshlight, except usually without the hard plastic exterior.

The overseas origin of this toy is also very important because it comes from a place that develop its sex toy industry & associated culture completely independently. There are a lot of things western toy producers wouldn't even consider doing that seem to be standard fare for the world of the Onahole. One thing there isn't a lot of is discussion as to worthwhile Onaholes, this might be because of the nature of sexual privacy in Japan or just a victim of circumstance. In my book, a good Onahole is easy to use & clean, feels good, won't end up in the trash a week later, and most importantly was worth the price in the first place.

There's going to be a lot of pictures in this article with non-English text on them and I will emphatically say I don't have the slightest idea what it means. A lot of them are still very entertaining in my opinion.

So with all these options, how can anyone tell which ones are worth it and which ones are trash? A dozen or so toys later and I have a few answers worth sharing:

Onahole Sleeve Summary

SLEEVE TEXTURE ONAHOLE BEST FOR
dctbl-table__imageMy Top PickOur Top PickErotic Number! Kokonoe (Soft Type)
  • If You're Looking For The Best Value
View On J-List →
dctbl-table__imageErotic Number! Touka (Hard Type)
  • If You Want Noticeable, Distinct Stimulation
View On J-List →
dctbl-table__imageRe:Ero Start a Pseudo-sexual Intercourse from Hole
  • If You Want A Long Lasting Toy
View On J-List →
dctbl-table__imageSaimin Seishidou - Tsubaki Miyajima
  • If You Want A Realistic Experience
View On J-List →
dctbl-table__imageInner Ecstasy Plump Wife (Original)
  • If You Want Lots Of Different Textures
View On J-List →
dctbl-table__imageCow Girl (Special Thick Onahole)
  • If You Want Something A Little Different
View On J-List →
dctbl-table__imageMoshimo Yankee Girl Virgin Onahole (MoshiYan)
  • If You Want A Tight Experience
View On J-List →
dctbl-table__imagePuni Ana F (Fellatio Toy)
  • If You Want A Blowjob
View On J-List →
dctbl-table__imageOnaman Three Sisters
  • If You Want Variety For Your Dollare
View On J-List →
dctbl-table__imageOkaa-san Online Onahole
  • If You Want A Soft Toy
View On J-List →

My Top Ten Picks For Onahole Pleasure

Erotic Number! Kokonoe (Soft Type)

Tight, ample size, great interior texture, affordable

Occasional relubing required, cleaning takes practice 

Plain and simple, the toy itself is very tight at the entrance due to "her sexual inexperience" while the toy itself is a lot more plush due to it being fairly thick overall. I'm pretty used to toys like the Fleshlight that are just more Western. This onahole quickly appealed to my sensibilities for a proper wank.

There's some cushion for the pushin' which really just means a lot more ability to grasp tightly and use the different parts of the great sleeve ridges to full effect.

Erotic Number! Touka (Hard Type)

Simple to clean, precise stimulation, beginner friendly

Stretches to capacity quickly, won't last indefinitely

Sold as the complete opposite of the hard type, this onahole apparently knows the score and is ready to play. For reasons unknown, this translates into her being much less squishy than Kokonoe. At least one thing about this toy matches up with its own biography in that it's meant to be a crowd pleaser.

The material works great as a male masturbator tailor built for really rubbing up hard against your willy. Some onaholes I tried out ended up being so soft and plush that I couldn't even notice the wild inner patterns. With this one, that was the least of my worries and I jerked my Jimmy to my delight. It might not be what everyone things is the absolute best, but I bet enough people would support it being nominated. 

Re:Ero Start a Pseudo-sexual Intercourse from Hole

Doesn't feel cheap, huge amounts of effort on exterior

Drying is not quick, shouldn't be turned inside out

Yes, I read the name of this toy too. I have no idea what pseudo-sexual intercourse really is but my closest guess is that it means whacking off.

It's heavier and dare I say a bit meatier than the onaholes I got that tended towards the cheaper range in price which was a welcome change for me. It's only about .9 of a pound but compared to toys that have the build integrity of a few condoms put together this one managed to feel significant.

Add that in to the tight entrance and tiny bit of posterior skin for some light booty clap action I was left very drained, very tired, but most importantly, very satisfied.

Saimin Seishidou - Tsubaki Miyajima

Very clever design, immersive, insanely memorable

Long term durability is unlikely, especially for larger men 

Just when you think you're done with the strange names, the really explicit box art decides to take things up a notch.

Supposedly a MILF with a light touch and a lot of tricks up her sleeve, actually using this onahole myself ended up leading me to a few different conclusions. The way the lips as well as the labia protrude forwards makes for perfect thigh-to-thigh type sensation when fully inserted. To be honest I wasn't entirely sure this one would end up working out for me as it is stated as only being 4.3 inches long, but it stretched very nicely and had me feeling as if it had some structures meant to feel better when stretched out. 

After that experience, I figured it was downright criminal to not give this onahole the props it deserves.

Inner Ecstasy Plump Wife (Original)

Very clever design, immersive, insanely memorable

Long term durability is unlikely, especially for larger men 

Onaholes tend towards the basic at the end of the day because I think they are meant to be reusable but should be able to be disposed of without worry if needed. That means a lot more variety as people try out different textures, but those individual textures can be just as basic as some of the sex toys from this side of the Pacific.

One of the few toys I've used that was a contender for the kind of experience offered by a Fleshlight would happen to be this plump maiden you see here today. That's more than likely due to the five different pleasure zones within the toy that remind me of areas I call pleasure domes inside of Fleshlights.

It is another great vagina onahole in that it doesn't shy away from a proper realistic vagina and makes use of the added hip shape to work as both a great handle for the toy and portion to collide into. There's just so much going on when in use that to me it's no huge secret why someone put a ring on it.

Cow Girl (Special Thick Onahole)

Simple to clean, very durable, varied corkscrew texture

More space required to store,  not particularly tight

What I'm usually expecting from a sex toy is the following: great pleasure potential, durable enough to be worth the money and shipping wait, and comfortable to use.

It really seems like those tastes often get fulfilled the most by onaholes that bill themselves as being more significant or thick or similar word for hefty. Over time I started noticing the type of anime girl used on the box and the experience on offer tended towards a few trends like the one I just mentioned. The corkscrew design of the interior with each portion of the "thread" being a different texture made for a lot more twisting than I thought I liked during my intimate time.

 They say once you've rode one cow girl you've rode them all. I just made that up, but my point is that there can be a lot more to male strokers than at first glance. Anyone looking for an onahole that goes more for stimulation from designed structures versus raw tightness need look no further.

Moshimo Yankee Girl Virgin Onahole (MoshiYan)

Can be handled roughly, easiest to use

Might be too tight for some, not very plush

Whenever I almost start to judge the fetish tastes overseas, I think about my wife's conversations about kink shaming and also how the fetishes that come up a lot here aren't a whole lot better. I'm looking at you, step-whatever fetish.

My experience with this onahole was entirely dominated by focusing on how tight it was. Extra lube sorted me out quickly but the onahole remained very aggressive. It absolutely seemed like the polar opposite of all of the "thick" onaholes in that it's not particularly stretchy diameter wise or all that plush.


To my surprise, this ended up winning me over as an onahole worth mentioning because at the end of the day it made for an extremely easy experience with consistent and strong sexual satisfaction power. No fuss to use, but a lot of reasons to come back and do it all again.

Puni Ana F (Fellatio Toy)

Well replicated mouth for blowjob play, good texture

Requires cleaning under "tongue", not for newbies

The name probably gave away what would make this toy special, it's their solution for blowjob toys much like how Fleshlight made the Turbo line catered to fellatio.

It's one toy on this list with a distinctive mouth orifice with noticeable face style lips versus vaginal style lips, but it gets even more out there. Inside this toy is a full throat section complete with moving tongue making it the only manual male stroker I've ever bought that managed to pull off an actual mouth, tongue and all. There's just enough movement from the tongue for it to not get in the way while it leads to an exotic onahole texture with a lot more ups and downs inside than on any toy I've bought from American manufacturers.

Onaman Three Sisters

Great toy variety for price, differences are noticeable

More storage space required, strange young aesthetic

Yes, this one is centered around three sisters of undetermined ages. The worst part of the weird gimmick they chose for the anime girls is that it's actually an awesome value with actual differences between them instead of just slightly switched up sleeves.

Each different option is different in all dimensions, tightness, and of course interior sleeve design. There's some colored letters to help you keep the apart and each sister is wildly different from the last. From the tight and inexperienced youngest to the more versatile oldest, the toys manage to all bring something different to the table and completely avoid feeling like they're all the exact same.

Once again, I am almost disturbed at how well their box personalities line up to their toy design.

Okaa-san Online Onahole

Simple to clean, very durable, varied corkscrew texture

Best parts are furthest away, requires finding sweet spot

Here's another MILFy option that of course doesn't buck the trend of a thicker overall toy. It goes quite far in the department of squishy fun if it means a bit less tightness overall. Since it's so plush it'll contour nicely but a lot of the finer work will be up to hand placement.

Slightly above average in weight, it passed the bar in raw pleasure output although I sensed it was lacking a little extra push. After some creative lubing and hand placement I was able to use the toy much more effectively. That's indicative it's just a pinch not tight enough at the right places, although it's definitely a proper candidate in this list compared to how flimsy some are.

A Quick Onahole FAQ

When browsing the deeper parts of the sex toy flavored internet for Onaholes you're sure to run into more than just a few strange terms that don't seem to have many context clues behind them. On top of that, there are a few major questions that always come up when people begin looking at sex toys that primarily got popular in Asia:

Where Can I Find Onaholes?

Tracking down a toy that's a true onahole is a bit difficult if you don't live in Asia. Most run of the mill sex shops will have toys more or less indistinguishable from onaholes if you look hard enough I'd imagine, but J-List was the only trustworthy option I could narrow down for the real deal. There's always some listings for some on marketplace sites or outdated machine-translated sites, those should really be avoided in the name of safety. 

Pretty much any male strokers that don't feature a case in their design are completely serviceable as onaholes. The main reason why you'd want to try out one of these toys is because the overseas sex toy industry developed kind of parallel to the sex toy industry here. There are different social norms and I'd imagine the buying habits and of course tastes are wildly different. What this means for us who enjoy a novel masturbation experience is that there are a lot more manufacturers trying to work at making the best sex toy from a closely related but different angle. 

As they say, variety is the spice of life.

Are Onaholes Generally Smaller Than Western Strokers?

They're made from stretchy materials and meant to be very tight & form fitting in the first place, so it's hard to say what's just general design philosophy or if they are actually any smaller. By and large though there isn't anything resembling a meaningful difference in the size of onaholes versus Western male masturbators.

Why Are All The Names So Strange?

You'll notice quickly that a lot of onaholes appeal to similar fetishes that are served by popular hentai/animated porn. So that means expect a lot of schoolgirl, virgins, or even tentacles to show up if only in name. Lots of onaholes put a hentai girl of some kind on the front of the box which is where most of the name comes from. Either things get lost in translation or in Japan there is a lot more desire to have a fleshed out fantasy to subscribe to behind the toy. The onahole has to belong to someone

Or it's none of those things, but who's to really say? I'm not entirely sure if there's an onahole historian to call.

What's The Deal With Onahole Weight?

I can't quite say for sure why so many onaholes display their weight so prominently.  A heavy onahole (typically 400g and above, or about 0.9 pounds) is usually about the same weight as a Fleshlight with the plastic case while a smaller one (200g or lower) will obviously weigh about half the usual Fleshlight which is about a pound or so.


 As far as experience goes, a heavier toy can feel more immersive when actually using the onahole while also usually giving a lot more squish to work with. Lighter toys are closer in experience to toys like the Tenga Eggs in that they're meant to stretch out more easily and won't be as thick.

My money's on it just being a big thing in Japan I won't ever be able to understand. Wouldn't be the first time!

How Can I Pick The Right Size Onahole For Me?

Plain and simple you should always be thinking practically when looking over these toys. Few of these toys won't stretch to accommodate but if you are particularly worried about size and fit then you should absolutely look for a toy that's a bit bigger than the average onahole. I've noticed myself that when shopping for your size it's always better to get a toy with more width than one with more length. Often times a toy can stretch very far lengthwise but will get very tight very quickly.

Over the course of my use of these special strokers no toy ever snapped or split in half during use for me although I could tell some were stretching permanently easier than others were. This was reassuring for me in that for most people a poorly sized toy is more likely to just not last as long as it should versus being a total bust. At the same time, it's absolutely not an excuse to not take care of your onahole just because it might be a bit snug!

About Don Watson

My name is Don Watson and I love to support my wife Angela's passion for human sexuality. It pays dividends for me personally and I enjoy writing about the topic as I'm a sexual person by nature. I concern myself with everything on the website that has to do with the male reproductive system to compliment my wife's female-oriented content. Have any questions? You can contact me via email.

Leave a Reply 0 comments

Leave a Reply: